Manchester City were found guilty in September 2026 of breaking Premier League financial rules for nine seasons, and the bill is starting to arrive before any punishment has been set. On 19 November the Financial Times reported that US lender Apollo Global Management walked away from a $2bn (about £1.5bn) loan to City's parent company, and on the same day the other Premier League clubs voted 18-2 to cover the league's directors if City's sponsors sue them.[1][6][8] City have appealed, the appeal is expected to be heard in mid-December, and a sanction will only follow if they lose.[7] Below: what the commission found, a breakdown of all 115 charges, the money in context, what punishment is realistic and the full timeline.
| Charged | February 2023[2] |
|---|---|
| Period covered | 2009-10 to 2017-18 seasons, plus non-co-operation to Feb 2023[2] |
| Charges | 115 (some reports say up to 130)[2] |
| Verdict | Guilty, September 2026; 114 of 115 upheld[6][7] |
| Sham sponsorship found | Over £830m[1][7] |
| Appeal lodged | 1 October 2026[7] |
| Appeal hearing | Mid-December 2026 (reported)[7][8] |
| Sanction | Not decided[1] |
| Lost financing | $2bn Apollo loan to City Football Group[6][8] |
What the commission found
The case is old. The Premier League charged City in February 2023 after a four-year investigation, an independent commission heard it behind closed doors for about 12 weeks from September 2024, and then the football world waited almost two years for a ruling.[2] When it came in late September 2026, it was close to a clean sweep for the league. The Athletic reported, and BBC Sport followed, that City were guilty of all but one count; the Manchester Evening News and talkSPORT put it at 114 of the 115 charges.[2][7][8]
The core finding is about sponsorship. The commission concluded that City used "sham" contracts with sponsors to disguise money that really came from the club's owners, Sheikh Mansour's Abu Dhabi United Group, and that this inflated revenue by more than £830m over nine years.[1][7] It also found nearly £17m in off-the-books payments to staff and players.[7] BBC Sport has also described the club's accounts as "inflated" by more than £900m in total, because the findings covered reduced costs as well as boosted revenue.[5] Premier League chief executive Richard Masters said City "systematically broke Premier League rules for nearly a decade".[1]
City reject all of it. The club says the ruling contains "clear material errors of law, principle and fact" and is "unsafe", and that it has "a comprehensive body of irrefutable evidence".[3][9]
The 115 charges, broken down
People say "115 charges" as if it were one thing. It is really five groups, and the biggest two are about paperwork and co-operation rather than spending. We took the BBC's list and worked out each group's share.[2]
Two points stand out. First, 54 charges, almost half, are about failing to give the league accurate financial information, which is where the sponsorship findings sit. Second, 35 charges, about 30%, cover the period from December 2018 to February 2023, after the alleged breaches ended. Those are about how City dealt with the investigation itself. The actual spending-rule breaches, Uefa's Financial Fair Play and the Premier League's Profitability and Sustainability Rules (PSR), are only 12 charges between them, about 10% of the case.[2]
Why a lender walked away
According to the FT, Apollo and City Football Group (CFG), the company that owns City and a network of other clubs, were in the final stages of a $2bn deal. The money would have refinanced existing credit lines and given the group extra cash. Apollo pulled out after the verdict, citing the uncertainty over what punishment is coming.[6][8][9] Apollo is no stranger to football: it lent to Nottingham Forest in December 2024 and has a majority stake in Atletico Madrid.[6][8]
Sheikh Mansour put about £100m of new equity into CFG around the end of October.[8][9] That is real money, but it is small next to what fell through. We converted the loan at about $1.31 to the pound, the rate implied in Sports Illustrated's own conversion of the £100m, which makes the lost loan roughly £1.5bn, about 15 times the owner's top-up.[9]
The chart makes one comparison that we think matters more than the loan. The £830m the commission says was dressed up as sponsorship works out at about £92m a season over nine seasons. BBC Sport counts City's net spend on transfer fees in the same 2009 to 2018 window at about £900m, on gross spending of roughly £1.2bn, more than any other club.[5] The two numbers are not the same money, since revenue also pays wages and running costs, but they are almost the same size. That is the heart of the rival clubs' complaint: without the disguised owner funding, City would not have passed the rules while spending like that.
For CFG the loan matters because lenders price risk. In 2019 Silver Lake paid a reported $500m for a stake that valued the group at $4.8bn, and chairman Khaldoon Al Mubarak has since put the group's worth at $10bn or more.[9] A $2bn loan would have been about a fifth of that $10bn figure. Until the case ends, every lender sees the same unknown: is this a club that will be in the Champions League, or one that could lose its place in the top flight?
What punishment could City face?
Under the rulebook the independent commission can impose whatever it thinks fits, from a fine to a points deduction. It can also recommend expulsion, but expulsion then needs a vote of the member clubs, and 15 of the 20 would have to back it.[7]
The only guide is what has happened before, and it is not much of one.
Everton were docked 10 points, cut to 6 on appeal, and later 2 more in a separate case. Nottingham Forest lost 4.[3] Each of those was a breach of PSR alone. City were found guilty on 7 PSR charges in the Premier League and 5 more involving Uefa rules, before you count the sham-contract and non-co-operation findings.[2][3] BBC Sport's analysis said some form of points deduction "now appears inevitable" if the appeal fails, and that it could be large enough to amount to relegation.[3]
Rival clubs want more than that. BBC Sport reported in October that executives at several clubs think a single relegation-sized deduction is too soft, because City would probably bounce straight back. Ideas they have floated include deductions spread across several seasons, transfer bans covering more than one window, titles taken away and left vacant, and a "tariff" system where City pay compensation to clubs based on where they would have finished.[4] Not every club agrees on stripping titles.[4]
Our read: a fine on its own looks very unlikely given that much smaller cases ended in points deductions. A deduction that keeps City in the league but out of Europe, plus some kind of transfer restriction, is the middle ground. Anything bigger raises the question the BBC raised in September: when would it apply, and to which season?[3]
The appeal and what happens next
City lodged their appeal on 1 October. Under Premier League rules a separate three-member Appeal Board must hear it within 12 weeks, and the hearing is reported to be pencilled in for mid-December, running over several days, with a decision expected in the New Year.[7] Counting 12 weeks from 1 October takes you to about 24 December, so the December date fits the rule.
This is not a re-trial. City have to show the commission made legal or procedural errors. The MEN reports that City are expected to argue the disputed sponsorship money came from the Abu Dhabi government as a sovereign body rather than from a private company.[7] If City lose, the case goes to a sanction hearing, and City can appeal whatever sanction comes out of that too.[7][8] Football finance adviser Stefan Borson told talkSPORT that even if City lose in December, "there's still two hearings remaining".[8] The MEN says a final legal end could slip to 2028 or even 2029.[7]
Sponsors, lawsuits and the 18-2 vote
The league now has a second front. Etihad Airways said within a day of the verdict that it was considering legal action, saying it "categorically rejects" any suggestion it was involved in improper commercial arrangements. Etisalat followed this month, calling the findings "entirely false and defamatory".[1][6]
Until now, the league's five board directors, including Masters and chair Alison Brittain, were only covered for legal costs if they won a case. At a meeting in London on 19 November the clubs voted to change the rules so the clubs pay the directors' legal costs if sponsors sue. BBC Sport's sources say only City and Nottingham Forest voted against; the other 18 voted in favour.[1] The change needed 14 votes to pass.[6]
| Date | Event | Ref |
|---|---|---|
| Feb 2023 | Premier League charges City with 115 breaches after a four-year investigation | [2] |
| Sep to Dec 2024 | Independent commission hears the case in private, about 12 weeks | [2] |
| Sep 2025 | Separate dispute over sponsorship rules (APT) settled | [2] |
| 25 Sep 2026 | Guilty verdict reported; City say they will appeal | [2] |
| 1 Oct 2026 | City lodge appeal | [7] |
| Oct 2026 | Etihad says it is considering legal action | [1] |
| Late Oct 2026 | Sheikh Mansour adds about £100m equity to CFG | [9] |
| Nov 2026 | Etisalat calls findings "false and defamatory" | [1] |
| 19 Nov 2026 | FT: Apollo ends $2bn loan talks; clubs vote 18-2 to indemnify directors | [1][6] |
| Mid-Dec 2026 | Appeal hearing (reported) | [7] |
| Early 2027 | Appeal ruling; sanction hearing if City lose | [7] |
Why this matters beyond Manchester
For US and other overseas readers, the Premier League is one of the most-watched sports leagues in the world and a major destination for American capital, from club owners to lenders like Apollo. This case is a test of whether a league can actually enforce its own financial rules against the richest owners in sport. If the verdict holds and the sanction is heavy, other leagues and investors will treat financial rules as a real risk. If it collapses on appeal, or drags on until 2029, the lesson will be that a big enough legal budget can outlast a regulator.
There is also a sporting cost right now. City, managed by Enzo Maresca, were top of the table when the verdict broke in September.[3] If the punishment does not land this season, every result in the 2026-27 Premier League, from the title to relegation, carries a question mark. Our FIFPRO World 11 2026 page covers the players at the top of the game this year, several of whom play in England.
Frequently asked questions
Were Man City found guilty?
Yes. An independent commission found City guilty in September 2026 of breaching Premier League financial rules between 2009 and 2018, upholding 114 of the 115 charges. City deny wrongdoing and have appealed.[2][7]
What punishment have Man City been given?
None yet. A sanction will only be decided if City lose their appeal, and City can appeal the sanction as well.[1][8]
When is the Man City appeal?
It is reported for mid-December 2026, within the 12-week window that runs from the 1 October filing, with a ruling expected in early 2027.[7]
Could Man City be relegated?
It is possible. The commission can deduct points, and some deductions could be big enough to relegate the club. It can also recommend expulsion, which would need 15 of the 20 clubs to vote for it.[3][7]
What is the $2bn loan story?
The FT reported that Apollo Global Management pulled out of a $2bn loan to City Football Group after the guilty verdict. The money was meant to refinance existing credit and add liquidity.[6][8][9]
Will Man City be stripped of their titles?
Some rival club executives want titles taken away and left vacant, but others oppose it, and it is not clear the commission would do this.[4]
References
- BBC Sport. "Manchester City charges: Premier League clubs to cover legal costs if sponsors sue". BBC. 19 November 2026.
- BBC Sport. "Manchester City charges: Premier League club found guilty of breaking majority of 115 financial rules". BBC. 25 September 2026.
- BBC Sport. "Manchester City charges: What punishment could club face after Premier League verdict and will they appeal?". BBC. 27 September 2026, updated 29 September 2026.
- BBC Sport. "Manchester City: Rival clubs want more than relegation from the Premier League". BBC. 6 October 2026.
- BBC Sport. "Man City guilty charges: Which clubs did 'inflated' money flow to in transfer market?". BBC. 2 October 2026.
- Aaron Morris and Jake Stokes. "Man City owners' $2billion loan scrapped as Premier League charges cause new blow". Manchester Evening News. 19 November 2026.
- Manchester Evening News. "Man City appeal 'to be heard next month' as date for potential punishment emerges". 13 November 2026.
- talkSPORT. "Man City owner suffers $2billion hit after guilty verdict on breaching Premier League rules". 19 November 2026.
- Sports Illustrated. "What Man City's '$2 Billion Hit' From Guilty Verdict Means for Future Transfers". 19 November 2026.